Supreme Court To Hear Plea Seeking Removal Of Videos Of Italian Politician Questioning Indian Elections At Bharat Summit

  • Supreme Court To Hear Plea Seeking Removal Of Videos Of Italian Politician Questioning Indian Elections At Bharat Summit

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday agreed to list a plea seeking the removal of social media videos featuring an Italian politician allegedly questioning the country's democratic system during the Bharat Summit 2026 organized by the Telangana Government in Hyderabad on November 13-14.The matter was mentioned before Chief Justice of India Surya Kant by Advocate Syed Rizwan Ahmad, who sought...

    The Supreme Court on Wednesday agreed to list a plea seeking the removal of social media videos featuring an Italian politician allegedly questioning the country's democratic system during the Bharat Summit 2026 organized by the Telangana Government in Hyderabad on November 13-14.

    The matter was mentioned before Chief Justice of India Surya Kant by Advocate Syed Rizwan Ahmad, who sought urgent intervention to take down the videos featuring Giacomo Filibeck, Secretary-General of the Party of European Socialists.

    Ahmad submitted that Filibeck, who was among the foreign delegates invited to the summit organized by the Opposition, had raised the slogan which was being used by the Congress to target the Indian election process ("Vote Chor, Gaddi Chhod") 

    Describing the remarks as a direct intervention in India's democratic affairs, the counsel said that the Italian delegate had not only raised the slogan but also translated it for other delegates attending the event.

    "A programme was conducted in Telangana under the aegis of the Government of Telangana and some foundations [...] Bharat Foundation. It was a coming together of a global alliance against fascist forces, organized by the main Opposition. Foreign invitees were also there and one person from Italy, he represents the European Socialist Party, directly intervened in the bona fide Indian democratic system. He used a very abusive slogan, since the urgency is of pulling down that slogan from social media, I need not repeat it here. And it appears, the Italian delegate translates the slogan for other delegates, and on my soil he is saying the government is corrupt here and it is not bona fide and that he will work with the opposition to restore democracy. It is a grave violation; it requires your intervention to pull down the video," Ahmed submitted.

    Responding to the mentioning, CJI Surya Kant said the matter could be listed on Friday. The counsel agreed.

    "Rest you argue before the concerned bench," the CJI said. 

    The petition, filed by one Zahid Ali, through AoR Pulkit Agarwal, seeks directions qua participation of foreign political representatives in India's domestic political affairs and campaigns with reference to alleged failure of certain authorities to ensure adherence to the applicable immigration, visa and regulatory framework. The petitioner particularly flags the Bharat Summit event at Telangana, claiming that Flilibeck's slogan was in bad taste and also derogatory to India's political processes. 

    The petitioner claims that Filibeck also referred to the protests against ECI's SIR of electoral rolls and endorsed the "political campaign" concerning the alleged irregularities. 

    "The participation of a foreign political representative in an Indian political campaign in this manner, including the raising of derogatory slogans and making prejudice political statements including the public endorsement of a particular political party and its leadership, raises a serious concern regarding the extent to which foreign political representatives may participate in or endorse the domestic political activities of an Indian political party violating the limits of International diplomacy, relations, ethics and corners of domestic political activities of India political parties while present within the territory of India, thereby raising questions concerning the permissible limits of international diplomacy and diplomatic relations." 

    Debby Jain

    Debby Jain is a Correspondent with LiveLaw, covering the Supreme Court of India

    Next Story