Articles

Kerala's Juvenile Age Debate Runs On Outrage, Not Evidence
Kerala's debate began with a crash involving a 19-year-old and a murder in which a 17-year-old stands accused. The law already reaches the gravest cases; international law points the other way, and the evidence is incomplete.Society's emotional outbreak over recent incidents can be strong enough to move lawmakers, especially when it concerns children. Thinking deeper, I suspect the outrage comes from the lack of agency of the group "children": they cannot speak for themselves in this debate, so...

Bilkis Bano Case: Convicts' Sentence Suspension Raises Questions
The Bombay High Court, while convicting 11 persons for the gangrapes and multiple murders in the Bilkis Bano matter, had said that the “truth and the falsehood are mixed up in such a manner that at every stage of investigation, the truth is hidden under layers of intentional laxity, omissions, contradictions, and falsehood, and the truth is required to be unearthed”.Bilkis Bano was 21 years old when she lost all members of her family in the diabolical and brutal crime that was driven by pure...

Counting Women's Unpaid Care Work Is Not Enough: Data Must Become Constitutional Duty
In the span of four days this October, the National Statistics Office announced two changes to how India counts work. On October 23, it released a press note on the Periodic Labour Force Survey (PLFS). From January 2027, the survey will ask people aged fifteen and above about unpaid household work, caregiving, volunteering, unpaid traineeships and production for own use. On October 26, it proposed new questions for the Annual Survey of Unincorporated Sector Enterprises (ASUSE), 2027-28. For the...

Meghalaya's Rat-Hole Coal: Constitutional Middle Path Left Untriggered
The rat-hole mining question in Meghalaya is almost always posed as a contest between two goods. On one side is tribal self-rule, because the coal lies beneath land owned by clans and families rather than the government. On the other is safety and ecology, because the National Green Tribunal called the way the coal is dug both unscientific and lethal. For more than a decade the two have been treated as irreconcilable, and the debate has run in that single groove. The framing hides a third option...

Fiction Of Party Intention: Rethinking Seat And Venue Conflict In Arbitration
The dispute resolution mechanism of Arbitration enjoys several advantages over court proceedings despite involving adjudication of the dispute, the most prominent being party autonomy which is expressed through the arbitration agreement between the parties. An arbitration agreement, apart from other things, is expected to describe something which is fairly simple such as if a dispute arises, where will the arbitration legally belong? However, even though the question may seem simple and...

Shrinking Contours Of “Ancestral Property”
There are only a few expressions in legal parlance that evoke as much interest as 'ancestral property'. Broadly understood, it is property that belongs to the male line and is inherited from one's father, grandfather or great-grandfather. It can't even be sold without the consent of the others. However, this popular understanding of ancestral property has not been the legal position for over seven decades.The Supreme Court recently reiterated this position in its judgment dated 6 November 2026...

A Year At Bar, Two Years In Training: Real Test Of Judicial Recruitment Reform
The Supreme Court's revised entry-level judicial recruitment model will succeed only if training, supervision and assessment are treated as substantive safeguards—not formalities.For more than two decades, law graduates could compete for entry-level judicial posts without first spending a prescribed number of years at the Bar. In May 2025, the Supreme Court reversed that position and restored a three-year practice requirement for candidates seeking appointment as Civil Judge (Junior Division)....
![Religious Conversion And Question Of OBC Entitlements [Part 2] Religious Conversion And Question Of OBC Entitlements [Part 2]](https://www.livelaw.in/h-upload/2026/06/15/500x300_679907-unity-in-diversity.webp)
Religious Conversion And Question Of OBC Entitlements [Part 2]
The Supreme Court's ruling in The Secretary to Government v. Sameer Ahamed N and Others has opened a Pandora's box of legal issues while upholding the Madras High Court's quashing of Tamil Nadu's 2024 order, which had extended Backward Class (Muslim) reservations to converts from SC, BC, MBC, and Denotified Communities after Dalit convert Sameer Ahamed N. was denied a 'Muslim Labbai' certificate by a Tahsildar. Relying on G. Michael v. S. Venkateswaran (1951)[1], the Supreme Court held that...

Beyond Access: Imagining Richer Idea Of Childhood
When Jawaharlal Nehru addressed children at New Delhi's National Stadium on November 14, 1957, he urged them to read, write, play, dance and sing, emphasising that the occasion should be celebrated as Children's Day rather than as an expression of personal affection for him. The date has carried that name ever since. Yet his message deserves attention beyond the annual ritual: by bringing together learning, play, intellectual effort and joy, Nehru articulated a conception of childhood that...

Restrained Without Signing: Indirect Competition And Limits Of Section 9
Companies often enter into agreements with non-compete clauses, especially when those agreements require them to provide confidential information and know-how. But what happens when the recipient attempts to run a competing business through a related entity that is not a signatory to the agreement? If the agreement contains an arbitration clause, can the sister concern be restrained without first deciding whether it is bound to arbitrate?In Parle Agro Private Limited v. Udayak Agro Products Pvt....

Statutory Boundaries Of Securities-Market Adjudication: SEBI, SAT And Limits Of Procedural Power
The securities market depends on a layered institutional structure. Trading Members (“TMs”) deal with investors, Professional Clearing Members (“PCMs”) provide clearing and settlement services to TMs, and the Clearing Corporation manages the settlement architecture. These arrangements are designed to contain counterparty risk. When a TM defaults, however, its clients' securities can be used and liquidated, leaving those investors exposed. That problem arose in Edelweiss Custodial Services...

From Marital Brinkmanship To Meaningful Co-Parenting, Re-Imagining Joint Custody, Visitation Rights And Co-Parenting
ContextChildren are often referred to as the centre of Indian families, the glue that holds everything together. But in family disputes, the child stands in-between its two warring parents. The timeless Russian author Leo Tolstoy's famous words that all happy families are alike but every unhappy family is unhappy in its own unique way, continues to hold relevance even today and more so when the child's custody and parenting is the point of contention. This Children's Day, we need to take a...
